Okay, that was funny
Daily Double. Category: Starts with a body part. Clue: Picture of a mouse-like critter with big ears and words "the fur of this is said to be 100 times softer than human hair." The leader had no idea... he just stood there until Alex prompted him for an answer. And then he said:
"What is a titmouse?.. I'm sorry."
(It was a chinchilla, actually.)
ps - Good lord, none of them came up with Oscar Wilde for an author's trial featuring "deviance, morality, and late-Victorian society"? (Two of the answers weren't even authors (Chatterly and Scopes), and the other guess was Dickens...)